Click to Home

Go To Search
Assessment Appeal Process

If you believe your assessment is incorrect, please feel free to contact the Town of Smithtown Assessor’s Office. Our staff will be happy to listen to your concerns regarding your assessment.

The following information may help you prepare for your meeting with us so that we may understand your situation:
  • Recent purchase contracts
  • Recent sales of similar homes in your neighborhood
  • Appraisal of your property, using applicable valuation date (usually prior July 1)

If you are not satisfied with the determination made by the assessor after the informal review process, a complaint may be filed with the Town of Smithtown Board of Assessment Review. The dates for filing the complaint form are between May 1st and the 3rd Tuesday in May. Grievance Day is always the 3rd Tuesday of May each year.

For additional information and grievance forms visit the State of New York tax website.

Board of Assessment Review

  • Michael Felice
  • H.C. Hoffman
  • Stacy Massina

Hours
Monday - Friday
9:00 am - 5:00 pm 

Summer Hours
(July 1 - August 31)
Monday - Friday
9:00 am - 4:00 pm

Peter D. Johnson Esq. IAO

Assessor
Email

Town Hall Annex
40 Maple Ave.
Smithtown, NY 11787 

Ph: (631) 360-7560
Fax: (631) 360-1704